134 nonobedience in absence of direct supervision

methods of noncooperation political noncooperation citizens alternatives to obedience
134 nonobedience in absence of direct supervision banner

"Another type of political noncooperation involves the population’s ignoring and noncompliance with laws, edicts and regulations in all situations where there is no immediate, direct supervision or enforcement. When soldiers are around to see that a particular order is carried out, for example, the population obeys; but when the soldiers leave, the people resume their noncompliance. This is a method that has often been used in China against unpopular regimes and foreign invaders. But this type of behavior is very difficult to document.88"...

((Sharp, Gene. The Politics of Nonviolent Action (p. 328). Albert Einstein Institution. Kindle Edition.))

recommend Potentially awesome partners

001 public speeches

public speeches

trending_up 9.2/10 as a pair
group_work In 4 campaigns together
141 civil disobedience of illegitimate laws

civil disobedience of illegitimate laws

trending_up 9.7/10 as a pair
group_work In 3 campaigns together
029 symbolic reclamations

symbolic reclamations

trending_up 9.3/10 as a pair
group_work In 3 campaigns together

warning Potentially problematic matches

065 stay at home

stay at home

trending_down 2.0/10 as a pair
group_work In 1 campaigns together
139 noncooperation with conscription and deportation

noncooperation with conscription and deportation

trending_down 2.0/10 as a pair
group_work In 1 campaigns together
117 general strike

general strike

trending_down 2.0/10 as a pair
group_work In 1 campaigns together

High scoring campaigns using this method

Historical cases from the Nonviolent Action Database that used this method

Chi Ha Kim’s Declaration of Conscience Delegitimizes Korean Dictator Park, 1975

10.0/10

Chi Ha Kim was a poet and playwright who gained prominence through his anti-establishment literature. He inspired many dissidents by inculcating them with courage to stand up against the illegitimate regime and exposing the corrupted nature of the cu...

Freedom Riders end racial segregation in Southern U.S. public transit, 1961

10.0/10

In 1947, the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE) conducted a “Journey of Reconciliation” to direct attention toward racial segregation in public transportation in the Southern U.S.A. Although this initial freedom ride campaign was not regarded as a gr...

Kumaon villagers campaign against British forest regulations, 1916-1921

10.0/10

From 1916 to 1921, villagers in Kumaon in northern India set hundreds of forest fires to protest the colonial British state’s increasing regulations of the natural environment.\n\nRural residents of Kumaon depended on forests as a source of firewood ...

British Ramblers campaign for greater access to right of ways and the right to roam (1985-2000)

9.0/10

The enclosure system involved fencing off plots of arable land. The land would then be deeded to an individual or group of owners who could use it as they saw fit. Despite slowly losing access to the commons, commoners preserved their access to right...

Bulgarians defend Jews from deportation during World War II, 1941-1945

9.0/10

Early on in the Second World War, Bulgaria was a member of the Axis powers, having signed the Tripartite Pact on March 1, 1941. However, Bulgaria was not emotionally attached to the ideals of the major Axis powers. They simply signed on because they ...

French Christians save Jews from Nazi holocaust, Le Chambon, 1940-1944

9.0/10

Le Chambon-sur-Lignon was a community located in south central France. With a history of being a refuge for persecuted Protestant Huguenots in 17th century, it was primarily a Presbyterian town.\n\nIn 1934 Andre Trocme arrived in Le Chambon with his ...

Women form peace camp to protest housing of cruise missiles at Greenham Common, 1981-1993

9.0/10

Greenham Commons outside Newbury, England was purchased in 1939 by the Newbury District Council for the public use of Newbury inhabitants, including the collection of firewood. In 1941 this area was requisitioned by the Air Ministry for an airfield, ...

American "Hikers" nonviolently resist Iranian prison guards 2009-2011

7.0/10

Normal.dotm 0 0 1 1000 5702 Swarthmore College 47 11 7002 12.0\n\n0 false\n\n18 pt 18 pt 0 0\n\nfalse false false\n\n/* Style Definitions */ table.MsoNormalTable {mso-style-name:"Table Normal"; mso-tstyle-rowband-size:0; mso-tstyle-colband-size:0; ms...

Oskar and Emilie Schindler intervene to save Jews from Nazi genocide, Poland, 1939-1945

7.0/10

Oskar Schindler was not your typical nonviolent savior. There is no doubt that his actions resulted in the saving of the lives of 1,200 Jewish Holocaust prisoners. What makes this story stand out among other nonviolent campaigns was the enormous and ...

British workers strike for better wages and political reform (“The Plug Plot Riots”), 1842

6.0/10

The Industrial Revolution brought prosperity to Britain’s upper classes and in the process created a new industrial working class. To this class belonged, in 1842, 350,000 textile workers, 120,000 coal miners, and 400,000 metal workers. Most of these...

Low scoring campaigns using this method

Historical cases from the Nonviolent Action Database that used this method

Luxembourgers general strike against Nazi occupation, 1942

2.0/10

In the 1940s, Nazi Germany under the government of Adolf Hitler was advancing its conquest of Europe during the Second World War. By May 1940, Luxembourg, a small neutral country bordering Germany, was placed under military occupation by forces of th...

Effectiveness profile

Success by Opponent
Corporation / Business 6.7
Educational Institution 7.0
Financial Institution 7.0
Government / State Body 8.3
Healthcare Provider 7.0
Judiciary / Legal System 8.5
Media Organization 7.0
Military / Police 7.0
Success by Theme
Success by Group Type
Success by Region
Success by Campaign Scale
Success by Goal Magnitude

Risk profile

Risk by region

Compared to the worldwide average for this method

Americas
skull
Lethal Force and Harm trending_flat Average
personal_injury
Physical Assault (Non-Lethal) trending_flat Average
gavel
Arrests and Legal Action trending_flat Average
campaign
Intimidation and Harassment trending_flat Average
lock
Restrictions on Rights and Freedoms trending_flat Average
house_siding
Property Damage and Economic Reprisals trending_flat Average
Asia
Europe

Risk by regime

Compared to the worldwide average for this method

Closed autocracy
Electoral autocracy
Electoral democracy
Liberal democracy